
Dear Matthew Spencer and Mary Morgan Stucky,
Matthew, I remember sitting down to write the first letter to you I ever addressed with your name, and thinking that this was something I wanted to remember forever. Every month leading up to that of your birth, I could hardly wait to address your letters with a name that belonged specifically to you. Up until then it was always a very heartfelt, but arbitrary “Dear baby,”. I hated having to write something so impersonal to the very individual who was supposed to be my firstborn son. It only brought to my attention more that at the end of the day, as much as I felt like I loved you, I really didn’t even know you yet. And that made me worry that maybe what I was feeling for you wasn’t really love at all. Maybe it was just excitement. Maybe once you were born, I thought, and you had a name, all of it would feel more authentic, and then I would know that what I was loving was truly you and not just the idea of having a child.
So on the afternoon that you arrived home from the hospital, just days after your name was branded on the certificate of your birth, and moments after you’d fallen asleep to the taste of my milk, I eagerly opened a journal to the first empty page I could find, and I very readily wrote the header, “Dear Matthew Spencer,” as if I had such an epic tale to tell you that I couldn’t even wait to begin.
But then I stopped. I tapped the book with my pen, and I looked at you for inspiration. And I had nothing.
For months, I would write pages upon pages to you, going on and on and ON at the pen about how I couldn’t wait for you to be here so that I could finally see who it was I’d been speaking to all of these months through the terms of endearment I put on pages like the blank one in front of me that day. But instead of feeling like I knew you more now that you were here, I only felt like I knew you so much less. I realized that when I was pregnant with you, it was like you were 9/10ths imaginary, and that made writing to you - a baby - somehow less absurd. There were bits and pieces of evidence that you existed, but in order to write to you, I had to believe that you were there, and imagine who you were. Once you were real, I couldn’t do that anymore.
I couldn’t get past the idea that you were a baby, and that essentially, you were a stranger.
In true female form, I’ve always written to sort through my thoughts. But honestly, I didn’t want you to know how badly in need of sorting my thoughts about you were. I half expected motherhood to come with some vast understanding of the Universe or something. That was always what people were saying, weren’t they? “Oh, yesterday I had my baby, and suddenly, it was like I’d found the meaning of life!” You were delightful and all, (Oh God, so delightful!) but when I looked at you on the day you were born and then again that day leaning over my journal, I felt more confused than ever about big picture questions like that. You didn’t bring with you any honorary enlightenment. Instead, it felt like the only thing you brought with you into my world was a disheveled mess of nervousness and uncertainty.
As hard as I tried to write the kind of letters to you I always dreamed of putting in your hands someday, I couldn’t find my voice. Whatever voice it was that I did have at the time was certainly not the kind you always imagine, radiating motherly wisdom and inimitable council.
You might notice that when Scarlett was born, I had no such hang-ups. I knew from the charming, effortless way that loving you unfolded itself onto my life like a dearly missed blanket from home -- that something extraordinary and perfect was waiting for me at the other end of her infancy. It didn’t matter to me anymore that I didn’t know exactly who she was from the moment I first started loving her. If she was anything like either of you, she was bound to be magnificent beyond anything I could have understood before then anyway.
For so long, I relished the opportunity to write as effortlessly to her as I’d always longed to be able to write to you, but couldn’t. In a way, it was almost like I was writing to all of you through the letters I wrote to her, because so much of the love that I have for all of you: you guys and your father, make the love I have for Scarlett what it is. Without you guys, I wouldn’t understand it the way that I do now. It’s like I was a rookie at love when I first met both of you, whereas now, because of you, I am a veteran. I may not know all there is to know about being the perfect mom, but mark my words, I know how to love you.
I wanted to remember how hard it was to write to you that day, Matthew, because I knew that that would change. I knew that someday I’d know every in and out of your personality; from the preeminent way to still your deepest fears, to your favorite color sprinkle to put on ice cream. And I loved the idea of being able to juxtaposition that kind of intense familiarity with where we started -- a moment in time when the love I had for you, however real, was so modest that it preceded even my ability to describe how or why it even existed. Being elbow deep into the lessons I was about step-motherhood (and all of the vast panic that that entails) I took immense solace in that.
Someday, you guys wouldn’t bewilder and overawe me so much. Someday, the idea of confidently parenting you wouldn’t feel like some far off ambition. Someday, I’d be a mother who could write to you about love, and impart wisdom unto you in relation to every facet of the subject. Today, I feel like that mother.
I’ve spent the past year of my life writing letters your baby sister, recording the firsts of her life and lacing every utterance to her with words of love and adulation. The first year just flies by so fast. But in that time you guys did a lot of growing, yourselves.
Matthew, you learned to pedal a bike and swim independently with a pair of water-wings over the summer. You developed an interest in farming (everything from modern-day cowboys to learning the ins and outs of growing crops and raising animals to utilize for food) and space. Your crowd of friends rivals that of your very popular eleven year old sister already, and you’ve already been caught trying to kiss a girl twice your age, you told me was your girlfriend. In fact some of Mary’s younger friends come to the door now, asking for you! (Boy are we in trouble.) You know how to roll the garbage can up from the curb after trash day, how to dress yourself, and how to feed the cat without spilling food from the bowl. You even helped me to rake up the leaves you jumped in this fall. You’ve read a whole slew of books at this point, and you even have a favorite author: Mo Willems. You memorized your address, your birthday, and how to respond in any number of emergency situations, including a house fire, getting lost, or coming face to face with Stranger Danger. You still like to fall asleep to music playing (although now, it’s country music or classic rock radio as apposed to a Mozart lullaby) and you’ve been binky-free for more than six months! Your number one favorite movie of all time is Tangled right now, and your biggest fear is a zombie invasion. Also, you peed outside for the first time, and you LOVED it.
Mary, you’ve experienced your very first taste of a romantic relationship with a real, live, idiot boy this year! Who you “broke up” with just two weeks later… (but then continue to talk about all the time with your friends). You ventured into a new school this fall and, brave as you are, took to it like a fish to water, and are trying your hand at cheerleading this term. You also went to your first school dance, and last week your aunt and I took you to get a second piercing in your ears. Your favorite author is Lauren Myracle. Your favorite movie trilogy is the Twilight saga. And though you have great taste in such a variety of real foods, your favorite is still Velveeta shells and cheese -- just like it was when you were six. (Do you remember when you had that project in first grade where you had to describe yourself and you butchered the spelling of macaroni and cheese in such an adorable way that Daddy and I hung it up on the wall of the kitchen? Not the refrigerator, but the actual wall! :-P ) You’re getting back into writing again and even keep a blog on a website called Figment.com, which is totally exciting for me, not just because you’ve always had a real gift for it (seriously, all of your teachers as far back as second grade have made note of it), but because our interest in writing is genuinely one of the ONLY personality traits that you and I can actually relate to each other about. Learning about you over that past year especially has been a little like learning a foreign language. FUCKING CONFUSING. But always really interesting, and definitely a lot of fun. I don’t have to tell you that the two of us are lucky to have the kind of relationship that we do, even if we had to go through a lot of un-fun crap to get to the comfortable place we’re at in this family… because I think we’re both pretty good at letting one another know how much the other means. But you and I bond over the fact that our lives didn’t turn out exactly how we expected. (After all, no one plans for their parents to divorce, or aspires to be a step-mom when they grow up.) But life has landed us here, and I honestly feel today like I couldn’t know you, or understand you, or love you any more if you were biologically my kid to call “daughter.” It might be kind of selfish, but this year one of the coolest things you’ve learned to do is call me mom -- something a part of me never expected you to do. You’ve almost always referred to me as mom. But this year, even after years of calling me by my first name, you’ve started calling “hey, mom!” downstairs to me when you need to ask a question or a favor, or exasperatedly huffing, “Mom! Please!” when you roll your eyes at some decision I’ve made that you shockingly object to. (I.E. every decision I make.) I could probably gush for an hour about how much this means to me, but I won’t only because I know enough about you to know that you’ll get all embarrassed. But it does, kiddo. It really, really, really, really does.
Basically, I just want you to know that you guys are goddamned awesome. When I think back to the days when I was little more than a stranger in your guys’ life, I just feel sad for the person I used to be. Not because I was less of a person, or because I was ever at all unhappy with my life as it was before you. But because you guys just have the power to do that. To make even the thought of not having you impossible to live with. Now that Scarlett’s more than a year, I’m going to write more letters to you guys too. Be warned ahead of time. There are many more words of love and adulation and things that will generally make you roll your eyes -- your gorgeous, handsome, perfect eyes -- where that came from.
Love you lots, guys,
Momma.











